| 4th Quarter Play-by-Play |
| Gc | 3-10 | on Gc26 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Gc | 3-10 | on Gc26 | Matt Flynn pass incomplete (Albert Leech). |
| Gc | 4-10 | on Gc26 | Brian Betley punt 40 yards to the MCD34, out-of-bounds. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 0:37 |
| Mcd | 1-10 | on Mcd34 | MCDANIEL drive start at 14:47. |
| Mcd | 1-10 | on Mcd34 | Eric Zwilsky rush for 3 yards to the MCD37 (Matt Dietz;S. Sullivan). |
| Mcd | 2-7 | on Mcd37 | TJ Develin rush for 2 yards to the MCD39 (S. Sullivan;Matt Dietz). |
| Mcd | 3-5 | on Mcd39 | Thomas Massucci pass complete to Nick Bender for 6 yards to the MCD45, 1ST DOWN MCD (Tim Widdoes;Dennis Bazow). |
| Mcd | 1-10 | on Mcd45 | TJ Develin rush for no gain to the MCD45 (Joe Delaney). |
| Mcd | 2-10 | on Mcd45 | TJ Develin rush for 7 yards to the GC48, out-of-bounds (Joe Delaney;Rob Pennella). |
| Mcd | 3-3 | on Gc48 | Thomas Massucci pass intercepted by Bryan DiSabato at the GC43, Bryan DiSabato return 0 yards to the GC43, QB hurry by Matt Coffey. |
| | Drive: 6 plays, 18 yards, TOP 3:09 |
| Gc | 1-10 | on Gc43 | GETTYSBURG drive start at 11:38. |
| Gc | 1-10 | on Gc43 | Jamel Mutunga rush for 12 yards to the MCD45, 1ST DOWN GC, out-of-bounds (Mike Weick). |
| Gc | 1-10 | on Mcd45 | Timeout McDaniel, clock 11:28. |
| Gc | 1-10 | on Mcd45 | Jamel Mutunga rush for 1 yard to the MCD44 (James Selfinger). |
| Gc | 2-9 | on Mcd44 | Matt Flynn pass incomplete (James Selfinger). |
| Gc | 3-9 | on Mcd44 | Jamel Mutunga rush for 9 yards to the MCD35, 1ST DOWN GC (Sam Cox). |
| Gc | 1-10 | on Mcd35 | TEAM rush for loss of 8 yards to the MCD43. |
| Gc | 2-18 | on Mcd43 | Matt Flynn pass complete to Ricky Manigat for 4 yards to the MCD39 (Mike Ford;Bill Gerdes). |
| Gc | 3-14 | on Mcd39 | Matt Flynn pass incomplete to Brian Betley (Chris Kolb). |
| Gc | 4-14 | on Mcd39 | Brian Betley punt 28 yards to the MCD11, fair catch by Matt Cahill. |
| | Drive: 7 plays, 18 yards, TOP 2:08 |
| Mcd | 1-10 | on Mcd11 | MCDANIEL drive start at 09:30. |
| Mcd | 1-10 | on Mcd11 | Thomas Massucci pass complete to Woody Butler for 4 yards to the MCD15 (Joe Delaney;Wes Taylor). |
| Mcd | 2-6 | on Mcd15 | Matt Cahill rush for 3 yards to the MCD18 (Tairi Mobley), PENALTY MCD holding 9 yards to the MCD9. |
| Mcd | 2-12 | on Mcd09 | 2nd and 12. |
| Mcd | 2-12 | on Mcd09 | Thomas Massucci pass incomplete to Woody Butler. |
| Mcd | 3-12 | on Mcd09 | Thomas Massucci pass complete to Tom Orrok for 8 yards to the MCD17, out-of-bounds. |
| Mcd | 4-4 | on Mcd17 | Jake Nichols punt 42 yards to the GC41, Charles Curcio return 7 yards to the GC48 (Travis Wenrich). |
| | Drive: 4 plays, 6 yards, TOP 1:41 |
| Gc | 1-10 | on Gc48 | GETTYSBURG drive start at 07:49. |
| Gc | 1-10 | on Gc48 | Charles Curcio rush for 4 yards to the MCD48 (Sam Cox). |
| Gc | 2-6 | on Mcd48 | Anthony DeSalva rush for 10 yards to the MCD38, 1ST DOWN GC (Mike Ford). |
| Gc | 1-10 | on Mcd38 | Anthony DeSalva rush for loss of 1 yard to the MCD39 (Albert Leech). |
| Gc | 2-11 | on Mcd39 | Ricky Manigat rush for loss of 2 yards to the MCD41 (Paul Smith). |
| Gc | 3-13 | on Mcd41 | Matt Flynn pass complete to Brian Betley for 22 yards to the MCD19, 1ST DOWN GC (Travis Wenrich). |
| Gc | 1-10 | on Mcd19 | Anthony DeSalva rush for 1 yard to the MCD18 (Albert Leech). |
| Gc | 2-9 | on Mcd18 | Matt Flynn pass complete to Gavin Jablonski for 13 yards to the MCD5, 1ST DOWN GC (Chris Kolb;Tommy Prazenica). |
| Gc | 1-G | on Mcd05 | Anthony DeSalva rush for no gain to the MCD5 (Tommy Prazenica;Mike Weick). |
| Gc | 2-G | on Mcd05 | Anthony DeSalva rush for 3 yards to the MCD2 (Tommy Prazenica;James Selfinger). |
| Gc | 3-G | on Mcd02 | Timeout Gettysburg, clock 04:07. |
| Gc | 3-G | on Mcd02 | Matt Flynn pass complete to Brian Betley for 2 yards to the MCD0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:00. |
| | | Matt Flynn pass attempt failed. |
| Gettysburg 20, McDaniel 19 |
| | Drive: 10 plays, 52 yards, TOP 3:49 |
| | | Mike Barrett kickoff 52 yards to the MCD18, TJ Develin return 25 yards to the MCD43 (Mike Barrett). |
| Mcd | 1-10 | on Mcd43 | MCDANIEL drive start at 03:54. |
| Mcd | 1-10 | on Mcd43 | Thomas Massucci pass complete to Nick Bender for 7 yards to the 50 yardline, out-of-bounds (Joe Delaney). |
| Mcd | 2-3 | on Mcd50 | TJ Develin rush for no gain to the 50 yardline (S. Sullivan). |
| Mcd | 3-3 | on Mcd50 | TJ Develin rush for 4 yards to the GC46, 1ST DOWN MCD (Matt Coffey). |
| Mcd | 1-10 | on Gc46 | Thomas Massucci pass complete to Ryan Procuccini for 8 yards to the GC38. |
| Mcd | 2-2 | on Gc38 | Thomas Massucci pass incomplete, QB hurry by Joe Ventresca. |
| Mcd | 3-2 | on Gc38 | Thomas Massucci pass incomplete (Joe Delaney). |
| Mcd | 4-2 | on Gc38 | Thomas Massucci pass complete to Matt Cahill for 6 yards to the GC32, 1ST DOWN MCD, out-of-bounds (Rob Pennella). |
| Mcd | 1-10 | on Gc32 | Thomas Massucci pass complete to CJ Billera for 3 yards to the GC29 (Joe Delaney). |
| Mcd | 2-7 | on Gc29 | Timeout Gettysburg, clock 01:15. |
| Mcd | 2-7 | on Gc29 | Thomas Massucci pass incomplete to Matt Cahill (Rob Pennella). |
| Mcd | 3-7 | on Gc29 | Thomas Massucci pass complete to Tom Orrok for 12 yards to the GC17, 1ST DOWN MCD (Tairi Mobley). |
| Mcd | 1-10 | on Gc17 | TJ Develin rush for 1 yard to the GC16 (Wes Taylor;Matt Coffey). |
| Mcd | 2-9 | on Gc16 | Timeout Gettysburg, clock 00:41. |
| Mcd | 2-9 | on Gc16 | Thomas Massucci pass complete to Woody Butler for 11 yards to the GC5, 1ST DOWN MCD (Wes Taylor;Tim Widdoes). |
| Mcd | 1-G | on Gc05 | Timeout McDaniel, clock 00:33. |
| Mcd | 1-G | on Gc05 | TJ Develin rush for 2 yards to the GC3 (Wes Taylor;Tim Widdoes). |
| Mcd | 2-G | on Gc03 | Timeout McDaniel, clock 00:01. |
| Mcd | 2-G | on Gc03 | Nick DeLuca field goal attempt from 20 GOOD, clock 00:00. |
| McDaniel 22, Gettysburg 20 |
| Mcd | 1-G | on Mcd30 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | Drive: 14 plays, 54 yards, TOP 3:54 |
